| Butler University Indianapolis | $111,570 | $103,454 | — | $45,980 |
| Purdue University-Main Campus West Lafayette | $103,280 | $116,745 | — | $9,992 |
| Indiana Wesleyan University-National & Global Marion | $82,615 | $79,415 | — | $8,216 |
| Indiana Wesleyan University-Marion Marion | $82,615 | $79,415 | — | $31,168 |
| University of Southern Indiana Evansville | $80,902 | $79,912 | — | $10,136 |
| Anderson University Anderson | $78,130 | $80,169 | — | $35,640 |
| Indiana State University Terre Haute | $72,402 | $66,602 | — | $9,992 |
| Oakland City University Oakland City | $72,235 | $87,480 | — | $27,150 |
| University of Indianapolis Indianapolis | $71,349 | $85,196 | — | $36,136 |
| University of Saint Francis-Fort Wayne Fort Wayne | $70,918 | $73,893 | — | $35,420 |
| Bethel University Mishawaka | $70,502 | — | — | $33,320 |
| Valparaiso University Valparaiso | $69,833 | $74,519 | — | $46,588 |
| Huntington University Huntington | $67,737 | — | — | $29,982 |
| Purdue University Northwest Hammond | $65,615 | $108,662 | — | $8,419 |
| Purdue University Global West Lafayette | $65,048 | $59,973 | — | $10,110 |
| Trine University-Regional/Non-Traditional Campuses Angola | $63,428 | $67,555 | — | $9,576 |
| Trine University Angola | $63,428 | $67,555 | — | $35,600 |
| Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College Saint Mary of the Woods | $63,405 | $52,229 | — | $33,490 |
| Indiana Institute of Technology Fort Wayne | $58,446 | — | — | $30,446 |
| Purdue University Fort Wayne Fort Wayne | $56,817 | — | — | $9,254 |
| Grace College and Theological Seminary Winona Lake | $54,982 | — | — | $30,034 |