Communications Technologies/Technicians and Support Services at Associated Technical College-San Diego

The earnings data here looks concerning at first glance—$19,841 isn't much above minimum wage for full-time work—but there's a crucial detail that changes the picture: this program carries exceptionally low debt at $9,500, giving it a debt-to-earnings ratio of 0.48. That's manageable debt for a short certificate program, particularly since 89% of students receive Pell grants and likely need an affordable entry point into the workforce. What's puzzling is the flat earnings trajectory from year one to year four, suggesting graduates either aren't advancing in their careers or aren't staying in the field.

The program ranks in the 60th percentile among California's two communications tech programs, which provides limited context but at least confirms it's competitive within the state. The 95th percentile national ranking is misleading—only 10 schools nationwide offer this specific certificate, making the comparison less meaningful than it appears.

For parents of students who need immediate workforce entry and can't afford traditional four-year programs, this represents a low-risk credential with minimal debt burden. However, the stagnant earnings should prompt serious questions about career advancement prospects. If your student pursues this path, make sure they have a clear plan for skill-building or additional certifications that could boost earning potential beyond $20,000 annually. This works as a stepping stone, not a destination.