Analysis
A debt-to-earnings ratio near 0.5 typically signals reasonable financial footing for a bachelor's degree, though peer programs in Minnesota suggest this picture may be conservative. The University of Minnesota-Twin Cities reports first-year physics earnings around $54,350—about $7,000 higher than the national median used to estimate Carleton's outcomes. That gap matters when you're looking at a selective liberal arts college with a 22% admission rate and median SAT scores near 1500. Students at this caliber often pursue graduate school or research positions that may not show their full earning potential in year one, which could explain why the estimated earnings trail the state benchmark.
The debt estimate of $23,120 aligns closely with both national and Minnesota medians for physics programs, falling well below the concerning thresholds that would strain typical starter salaries. For a private college of Carleton's selectivity, this figure suggests meaningful financial aid for most students. Still, with only 14% receiving Pell grants, families should verify actual aid packages carefully rather than assuming the median experience will apply to them.
The core question is whether Carleton's physics program delivers value beyond what the numbers capture—graduate school placement, research opportunities, or career outcomes that materialize after year one. If your student plans to work immediately after graduation rather than pursue advanced degrees, the in-state public option shows stronger early earnings at likely lower cost.
Where Carleton College Stands
Earnings vs. debt across all physics bachelors's programs nationally
Compare to Similar Programs in Minnesota
Physics bachelors's programs at peer institutions in Minnesota (21 total in state)
Scroll to see more →
| School | In-State Tuition | Earnings (1yr)* | Earnings (4yr) | Median Debt* | Debt/Earnings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $65,457 | $47,670* | — | $23,120* | — | |
| $16,488 | $54,350* | $57,831 | $23,594* | 0.43 | |
| National Median | — | $47,670* | — | $23,304* | 0.49 |
Career Paths
Occupations commonly associated with physics graduates
Physicists
Natural Sciences Managers
Clinical Research Coordinators
Water Resource Specialists
Physics Teachers, Postsecondary
Secondary School Teachers, Except Special and Career/Technical Education
About This Data
Source: U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard (October 2025 release)
Population: Graduates who received federal financial aid (Title IV grants or loans). At Carleton College, approximately 14% of students receive Pell grants. Students who did not receive federal aid are not included in these figures.
Earnings: Median earnings from IRS W-2 data for graduates who are employed and not enrolled in further education, measured 1 year after completion. Earnings are pre-tax and include wages, salaries, and self-employment income.
Debt: Median cumulative federal loan debt at graduation. Does not include private loans or Parent PLUS loans borrowed on behalf of students.
Estimated Earnings: Actual earnings data is not available for this program (typically due to privacy thresholds when fewer than 30 graduates reported earnings). The estimate shown is based on the national median of 75 similar programs. Actual outcomes may vary.