Analysis
Erie 1 BOCES graduates earn about $2,000 less than typical New York cosmetology programs in their first year, placing them below the state median despite slightly higher debt loads. The starting salary of $15,359 means graduates would need nearly eight months of full earnings just to cover their $9,500 in student debt, though the relatively modest loan burden keeps this manageable compared to many vocational programs.
The 25% earnings jump to $19,190 by year four offers some reassurance—graduates do see meaningful income growth as they build clientele and skills. However, even with that improvement, they're still earning about $3,000 less annually than graduates from top-performing New York cosmetology schools like Continental School of Beauty Culture (also in West Seneca) or Aesthetic Science Institute. That gap compounds over time and raises questions about why this program lags behind competitors in the same metro area.
For families considering this program, the key question is whether location convenience or familiarity with BOCES justifies accepting below-median outcomes. The debt won't be crushing, but your child will likely start their cosmetology career at a financial disadvantage compared to peers from stronger programs. If other accredited schools are accessible, the earnings difference could be worth the extra research.
Where Erie 1 BOCES Stands
Earnings vs. debt across all cosmetology certificate's programs nationally
Earnings Distribution
How Erie 1 BOCES graduates compare to all programs nationally
Earnings Over Time
How earnings evolve from 1 year to 4 years after graduation
| School | 1 Year | 4 Years | Growth |
|---|---|---|---|
| Erie 1 BOCES | $15,359 | $19,190 | +25% |
| Paul Mitchell the School-Schenectady | $17,570 | $27,864 | +59% |
| New York School of Esthetics & Day Spa | $20,531 | $25,426 | +24% |
| Arrojo Cosmetology School | $18,528 | $25,400 | +37% |
| The Salon Professional Academy-Tonawanda | $17,534 | $25,281 | +44% |
Compare to Similar Programs in New York
Cosmetology certificate's programs at peer institutions in New York (46 total in state)
| School | Earnings (1yr) | Earnings (4yr) | Median Debt | Debt/Earnings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $15,359 | $19,190 | $9,500 | 0.62 | |
| $22,638 | $25,225 | $6,333 | 0.28 | |
| $22,221 | $12,258 | $9,500 | 0.43 | |
| $22,092 | $22,106 | $9,847 | 0.45 | |
| $21,516 | $24,650 | $6,333 | 0.29 | |
| $20,531 | $25,426 | $6,625 | 0.32 | |
| National Median | $17,113 | — | $9,862 | 0.58 |
About This Data
Source: U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard (October 2025 release)
Population: Graduates who received federal financial aid (Title IV grants or loans). At Erie 1 BOCES, approximately 38% of students receive Pell grants. Students who did not receive federal aid are not included in these figures.
Earnings: Median earnings from IRS W-2 data for graduates who are employed and not enrolled in further education, measured 1 year after completion. Earnings are pre-tax and include wages, salaries, and self-employment income.
Debt: Median cumulative federal loan debt at graduation. Does not include private loans or Parent PLUS loans borrowed on behalf of students.
Sample Size: Based on 51 graduates with reported earnings and 37 graduates with debt data. Small samples may not be representative.