Mathematics and Statistics at Keuka College

Based on comparable mathematics and statistics programs in New York, Keuka College graduates appear to start around $55,490—placing them squarely at the state median but nearly $4,000 below the national benchmark for this field. The estimated $21,250 debt load is manageable, creating a debt-to-earnings ratio of 0.38 that suggests graduates could reasonably pay off loans within four to five years. However, it's worth noting that New York's top-performing math programs deliver substantially higher returns, with NYU graduates earning nearly $25,000 more in their first year.

The real question is whether this program provides adequate preparation for competitive math and statistics careers. With a 94% admission rate and average SAT of 1090, Keuka serves a different student population than research universities, yet the earnings gap compared to stronger programs is significant. Fields like mathematics and statistics typically reward analytical rigor and quantitative training—areas where program quality matters considerably for landing well-paying roles in data science, actuarial work, or quantitative analysis.

For families considering Keuka's math program, the estimated debt burden won't be crushing, but the earnings trajectory deserves scrutiny. If your student has the academic profile to access more selective programs in New York—even public options like University at Albany—the earning premium could be worth pursuing. Otherwise, ensure this program provides robust internship connections and career placement support to help graduates compete for positions that justify the investment.