| Butler University Indianapolis | $50,707 | $45,302 | $27,000 | $45,980 |
| Indiana University-Northwest Gary | $48,497 | $43,671 | $31,000 | $8,179 |
| Franklin College Franklin | $47,610 | — | $27,000 | $37,350 |
| Indiana University-Bloomington Bloomington | $46,765 | $44,741 | $23,741 | $11,790 |
| Indiana University-Indianapolis Indianapolis | $46,744 | $43,547 | $23,000 | $10,449 |
| Purdue University-Main Campus West Lafayette | $45,459 | $43,083 | $18,646 | $9,992 |
| Taylor University Upland | $45,389 | $44,542 | $25,000 | $39,104 |
| University of Indianapolis Indianapolis | $45,250 | $44,581 | $27,000 | $36,136 |
| Valparaiso University Valparaiso | $45,123 | $44,455 | $27,000 | $46,588 |
| Manchester University North Manchester | $45,088 | — | — | $37,090 |
| Purdue University Northwest Hammond | $45,071 | $42,599 | $27,000 | $8,419 |
| Anderson University Anderson | $44,851 | $40,545 | $26,851 | $35,640 |
| Bethel University Mishawaka | $44,583 | $38,477 | $27,000 | $33,320 |
| Indiana University-Southeast New Albany | $43,243 | $40,348 | $24,145 | $8,179 |
| Indiana University-South Bend South Bend | $43,128 | $41,995 | $26,000 | $8,179 |
| Grace College and Theological Seminary Winona Lake | $41,955 | — | $15,250 | $30,034 |
| Ball State University Muncie | $41,821 | $40,405 | $24,655 | $10,758 |
| University of Southern Indiana Evansville | $41,510 | $39,232 | $23,500 | $10,136 |
| Indiana Wesleyan University-Marion Marion | $41,318 | $40,017 | $24,739 | $31,168 |
| Indiana Wesleyan University-National & Global Marion | $41,318 | $40,017 | $24,739 | $8,216 |
| Saint Mary's College Notre Dame | $41,286 | $46,956 | $27,000 | $51,430 |
| Purdue University Fort Wayne Fort Wayne | $41,090 | $43,083 | $25,834 | $9,254 |
| Indiana University-Kokomo Kokomo | $40,553 | $38,065 | $25,885 | $8,179 |
| Indiana State University Terre Haute | $40,204 | $41,705 | $25,000 | $9,992 |
| Marian University Indianapolis | $38,978 | $41,651 | $27,000 | $39,100 |
| Indiana University-East Richmond | $38,610 | $38,498 | $25,866 | $8,179 |
| Purdue University Global West Lafayette | $21,819 | $28,654 | $57,500 | $10,110 |